232-] English Literature
George Bernard Shaw
Stage success: 1900–1914
During
the first decade of the twentieth century, Shaw secured a firm reputation as a
playwright. In 1904 J. E. Vedrenne and Harley Granville-Barker established a
company at the Royal Court Theatre in Sloane Square, Chelsea to present modern
drama. Over the next five years they staged fourteen of Shaw's plays. The
first, John Bull's Other Island, a comedy about an Englishman in Ireland,
attracted leading politicians and was seen by Edward VII, who laughed so much
that he broke his chair. The play was withheld from Dublin's Abbey Theatre, for
fear of the affront it might provoke, although it was shown at the city's Royal
Theatre in November 1907. Shaw later wrote that William Butler Yeats, who had
requested the play, "got rather more than he bargained for ... It was
uncongenial to the whole spirit of the neo-Gaelic movement, which is bent on
creating a new Ireland after its own ideal, whereas my play is a very
uncompromising presentment of the real old Ireland." Nonetheless, Shaw and
Yeats were close friends; Yeats and Lady Gregory tried unsuccessfully to
persuade Shaw to take up the vacant co-directorship of the Abbey Theatre after
J. M. Synge's death in 1909. Shaw admired other figures in the Irish Literary
Revival, including George Russell and James Joyce, and was a close friend of
Seán O'Casey, who was inspired to become a playwright after reading John Bull's
Other Island.
Man
and Superman, completed in 1902, was a success both at the Royal Court in 1905
and in Robert Loraine's New York production in the same year. Among the other
Shaw works presented by Vedrenne and Granville-Barker were Major Barbara
(1905), depicting the contrasting morality of arms manufacturers and the
Salvation Army; The Doctor's Dilemma (1906), a mostly serious piece about
professional ethics; and Caesar and Cleopatra, Shaw's counterblast to
Shakespeare's Antony and Cleopatra, seen in New York in 1906 and in London the
following year.
Now
prosperous and established, Shaw experimented with unorthodox theatrical forms
described by his biographer Stanley Weintraub as "discussion drama"
and "serious farce". These plays included Getting Married (premiered
1908), The Shewing-Up of Blanco Posnet (1909), Misalliance (1910), and Fanny's
First Play (1911). Blanco Posnet was banned on religious grounds by the Lord
Chamberlain (the official theatre censor in England), and was produced instead
in Dublin; it filled the Abbey Theatre to capacity. Fanny's First Play, a
comedy about suffragettes, had the longest initial run of any Shaw play—622
performances.
Androcles
and the Lion (1912), a less heretical study of true and false religious
attitudes than Blanco Posnet, ran for eight weeks in September and October
1913. It was followed by one of Shaw's most successful plays, Pygmalion,
written in 1912 and staged in Vienna the following year, and in Berlin shortly
afterwards. Shaw commented, "It is the custom of the English press when a
play of mine is produced, to inform the world that it is not a play—that it is
dull, blasphemous, unpopular, and financially unsuccessful. ... Hence arose an
urgent demand on the part of the managers of Vienna and Berlin that I should
have my plays performed by them first." The British production opened in
April 1914, starring Sir Herbert Tree and Mrs Patrick Campbell as,
respectively, a professor of phonetics and a cockney flower-girl. There had
earlier been a romantic liaison between Shaw and Campbell that caused Charlotte
Shaw considerable concern, but by the time of the London premiere it had ended.
The play attracted capacity audiences until July, when Tree insisted on going
on holiday, and the production closed. His co-star then toured with the piece
in the US.
Fabian years: 1900–1913
In
1899, when the Boer War began, Shaw wished the Fabians to take a neutral stance
on what he deemed, like Home Rule, to be a "non-Socialist" issue.
Others, including the future Labour prime minister Ramsay MacDonald, wanted
unequivocal opposition, and resigned from the society when it followed Shaw. In
the Fabians' war manifesto, Fabianism and the Empire (1900), Shaw declared that
"until the Federation of the World becomes an accomplished fact we must
accept the most responsible Imperial federations available as a substitute for
it".
As
the new century began, Shaw became increasingly disillusioned by the limited
impact of the Fabians on national politics. Thus, although a nominated Fabian
delegate, he did not attend the London conference at the Memorial Hall,
Farringdon Street in February 1900, that created the Labour Representation
Committee—precursor of the modern Labour Party. By 1903, when his term as
borough councillor expired, he had lost his earlier enthusiasm, writing:
"After six years of Borough Councilling I am convinced that the borough
councils should be abolished". Nevertheless, in 1904 he stood in the
London County Council elections. After an eccentric campaign, which Holroyd
characterises as "[making] absolutely certain of not getting in", he
was duly defeated. It was Shaw's final foray into electoral politics.
Nationally, the 1906 general election produced a huge Liberal majority and an
intake of 29 Labour members. Shaw viewed this outcome with scepticism; he had a
low opinion of the new prime minister, Sir Henry Campbell-Bannerman, and saw
the Labour members as inconsequential: "I apologise to the Universe for my
connection with such a body".
In
the years after the 1906 election, Shaw felt that the Fabians needed fresh
leadership, and saw this in the form of his fellow-writer H. G. Wells, who had
joined the society in February 1903. Wells's ideas for reform—particularly his
proposals for closer cooperation with the Independent Labour Party—placed him
at odds with the society's "Old Gang", led by Shaw. According to
Cole, Wells "had minimal capacity for putting [his ideas] across in public
meetings against Shaw's trained and practised virtuosity". In Shaw's view,
"the Old Gang did not extinguish Mr Wells, he annihilated himself". Wells
resigned from the society in September 1908; Shaw remained a member, but left
the executive in April 1911. He later wondered whether the Old Gang should have
given way to Wells some years earlier: "God only knows whether the Society
had not better have done it". Although less active—he blamed his advancing
years—Shaw remained a Fabian.
In
1912 Shaw invested £1,000 for a one-fifth share in the Webbs' new publishing
venture, a socialist weekly magazine called The New Statesman, which appeared
in April 1913. He became a founding director, publicist, and in due course a
contributor, mostly anonymously. He was soon at odds with the magazine's
editor, Clifford Sharp, who by 1916 was rejecting his contributions—"the
only paper in the world that refuses to print anything by me", according
to Shaw.
First World War
After
the First World War began in August 1914, Shaw produced his tract Common Sense
About the War, which argued that the warring nations were equally culpable.
Such a view was anathema in an atmosphere of fervent patriotism, and offended
many of Shaw's friends; Ervine records that "is appearance at any public
function caused the instant departure of many of those present."
Despite
his errant reputation, Shaw's propagandist skills were recognised by the
British authorities, and early in 1917 he was invited by Field Marshal Haig to
visit the Western Front battlefields. Shaw's 10,000-word report, which
emphasised the human aspects of the soldier's life, was well received, and he
became less of a lone voice. In April 1917 he joined the national consensus in
welcoming America's entry into the war: "a first class moral asset to the
common cause against junkerism".
Three
short plays by Shaw were premiered during the war. The Inca of Perusalem,
written in 1915, encountered problems with the censor for burlesquing not only
the enemy but the British military command; it was performed in 1916 at the
Birmingham Repertory Theatre. O'Flaherty V.C., satirising the government's
attitude to Irish recruits, was banned in the UK and was presented at a Royal
Flying Corps base in Belgium in 1917. Augustus Does His Bit, a genial farce,
was granted a licence; it opened at the Royal Court in January 1917.
Ireland
Shaw
had long supported the principle of Irish Home Rule within the British Empire
(which he thought should become the British Commonwealth). In April 1916 he
wrote scathingly in The New York Times about militant Irish nationalism:
"In point of learning nothing and forgetting nothing these fellow-patriots
of mine leave the Bourbons nowhere." Total independence, he asserted, was
impractical; alliance with a bigger power (preferably England) was essential.
The Dublin Easter Rising later that month took him by surprise. After its
suppression by British forces, he expressed horror at the summary execution of
the rebel leaders, but continued to believe in some form of Anglo-Irish union.
In How to Settle the Irish Question (1917), he envisaged a federal arrangement,
with national and imperial parliaments. Holroyd records that by this time the
separatist party Sinn Féin was in the ascendency, and Shaw's and other moderate
schemes were forgotten.
In
the postwar period, Shaw despaired of the British government's coercive
policies towards Ireland, and joined his fellow-writers Hilaire Belloc and G.
K. Chesterton in publicly condemning these actions. The Anglo-Irish Treaty of
December 1921 led to the partition of Ireland between north and south, a
provision that dismayed Shaw. In 1922 civil war broke out in the south between
its pro-treaty and anti-treaty factions, the former of whom had established the
Irish Free State. Shaw visited Dublin in August, and met Michael Collins, then
head of the Free State's Provisional Government. Shaw was much impressed by
Collins, and was saddened when, three days later, the Irish leader was ambushed
and killed by anti-treaty forces. In a letter to Collins's sister, Shaw wrote:
"I met Michael for the first and last time on Saturday last, and am very
glad I did. I rejoice in his memory, and will not be so disloyal to it as to
snivel over his valiant death". Shaw remained a British subject all his
life, but took dual British-Irish nationality in 1934.