32- ] American Literature
Robert Frost
Robert
Frost, in full Robert Lee Frost, (born March 26, 1874, San Francisco,
California, U.S.—died January 29, 1963, Boston, Massachusetts), American poet
who was much admired for his depictions of the rural life of New England, his
command of American colloquial speech, and his realistic verse portraying
ordinary people in everyday situations.
His
work was initially published in England before it was published in the United
States. Known for his realistic depictions of rural life and his command of
American colloquial speech, Frost frequently wrote about settings from rural
life in New England in the early 20th century, using them to examine complex
social and philosophical themes.
Frequently
honored during his lifetime, Frost is the only poet to receive four Pulitzer
Prizes for Poetry. He became one of America's rare "public literary
figures, almost an artistic institution". He was awarded the Congressional
Gold Medal in 1960 for his poetic works. On July 22, 1961, Frost was named poet
laureate of Vermont.
Robert
Frost was born in San Francisco, but his family moved to Lawrence,
Massachusetts, in 1884 following his father’s death. The move was actually a
return, for Frost’s ancestors were originally New Englanders, and Frost became
famous for his poetry’s engagement with New England locales, identities, and
themes. Frost graduated from Lawrence High School, in 1892, as class poet (he
also shared the honor of co-valedictorian with his wife-to-be Elinor White),
and two years later, the New York Independent accepted his poem entitled “My
Butterfly,” launching his status as a professional poet with a check for
$15.00. Frost's first book was published around the age of 40, but he would go
on to win a record four Pulitzer Prizes and become the most famous poet of his
time, before his death at the age of 88.
To celebrate his first publication, Frost had
a book of six poems privately printed; two copies of Twilight were made—one for
himself and one for his fiancee. Over the next eight years, however, he
succeeded in having only 13 more poems published. During this time, Frost
sporadically attended Dartmouth and Harvard and earned a living teaching school
and, later, working a farm in Derry, New Hampshire. But in 1912, discouraged by
American magazines’ constant rejection of his work, he took his family to
England, where he found more professional success. Continuing to write about
New England, he had two books published, A Boy’s Will (1913) and North of
Boston (1914), which established his reputation so that his return to the
United States in 1915 was as a celebrated literary figure. Holt put out an
American edition of North of Boston in 1915, and periodicals that had once
scorned his work now sought it.
Frost’s
position in American letters was cemented with the publication of North of
Boston, and in the years before his death he came to be considered the unofficial
poet laureate of the United States. On his 75th birthday, the US Senate passed
a resolution in his honor which said, “His poems have helped to guide American
thought and humor and wisdom, setting forth to our minds a reliable
representation of ourselves and of all men.” In 1955, the State of Vermont
named a mountain after him in Ripton, the town of his legal residence; and at
the presidential inauguration of John F. Kennedy in 1961, Frost was given the
unprecedented honor of being asked to read a poem. Frost wrote a poem called
“Dedication” for the occasion, but could not read it given the day’s harsh
sunlight. He instead recited “The Gift Outright,” which Kennedy had originally
asked him to read, with a revised, more forward-looking, last line.
Though
Frost allied himself with no literary school or movement, the imagists helped
at the start to promote his American reputation. Poetry: A Magazine of Verse
published his work before others began to clamor for it. It also published a
review by Ezra Pound of the British edition of A Boy’s Will, which Pound said
“has the tang of the New Hampshire woods, and it has just this utter sincerity.
It is not post-Miltonic or post-Swinburnian or post Kiplonian. This man has the
good sense to speak naturally and to paint the thing, the thing as he sees it.”
Amy Lowell reviewed North of Boston in the New Republic, and she, too, sang
Frost’s praises: “He writes in classic metres in a way to set the teeth of all
the poets of the older schools on edge; and he writes in classic metres, and
uses inversions and cliches whenever he pleases, those devices so abhorred by
the newest generation. He goes his own way, regardless of anyone else’s rules,
and the result is a book of unusual power and sincerity.” In these first two
volumes, Frost introduced not only his affection for New England themes and his
unique blend of traditional meters and colloquialism, but also his use of
dramatic monologues and dialogues. “Mending Wall,” the leading poem in North of
Boston, describes the friendly argument between the speaker and his neighbor as
they walk along their common wall replacing fallen stones; their differing
attitudes toward “boundaries” offer symbolic significance typical of the poems
in these early collections.
Mountain Interval marked Frost’s turn to
another kind of poem, a brief meditation sparked by an object, person or event.
Like the monologues and dialogues, these short pieces have a dramatic quality.
“Birches,” discussed above, is an example, as is “The Road Not Taken,” in which
a fork in a woodland path transcends the specific. The distinction of this
volume, the Boston Transcript said, “is that Mr. Frost takes the lyricism of A
Boy’s Will and plays a deeper music and gives a more intricate variety of
experience.”
Several new qualities emerged in Frost’s work
with the appearance of New Hampshire (1923), particularly a new
self-consciousness and willingness to speak of himself and his art. The volume,
for which Frost won his first Pulitzer Prize, “pretends to be nothing but a long
poem with notes and grace notes,” as Louis Untermeyer described it. The title
poem, approximately fourteen pages long, is a “rambling tribute” to Frost’s
favorite state and “is starred and dotted with scientific numerals in the
manner of the most profound treatise.” Thus, a footnote at the end of a line of
poetry will refer the reader to another poem seemingly inserted to merely
reinforce the text of “New Hampshire.” Some of these poems are in the form of
epigrams, which appear for the first time in Frost’s work. “Fire and Ice,” for
example, one of the better known epigrams, speculates on the means by which the
world will end. Frost’s most famous and, according to J. McBride Dabbs, most
perfect lyric, “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening,” is also included in this
collection; conveying “the insistent whisper of death at the heart of life,”
the poem portrays a speaker who stops his sleigh in the midst of a snowy woods
only to be called from the inviting gloom by the recollection of practical
duties. Frost himself said of this poem that it is the kind he’d like to print
on one page followed with “forty pages of footnotes.”
West-Running
Brook (1928), Frost’s fifth book of poems, is divided into six sections, one of
which is taken up entirely by the title poem. This poem refers to a brook which
perversely flows west instead of east to the Atlantic like all other brooks. A
comparison is set up between the brook and the poem’s speaker who trusts
himself to go by “contraries”; further rebellious elements exemplified by the
brook give expression to an eccentric individualism, Frost’s stoic theme of
resistance and self-realization. Reviewing the collection in the New York
Herald Tribune, Babette Deutsch wrote: “The courage that is bred by a dark
sense of Fate, the tenderness that broods over mankind in all its blindness and
absurdity, the vision that comes to rest as fully on kitchen smoke and lapsing
snow as on mountains and stars—these are his, and in his seemingly casual
poetry, he quietly makes them ours.”
A Further Range (1936), which earned Frost
another Pulitzer Prize and was a Book-of-the-Month Club selection, contains two
groups of poems subtitled “Taken Doubly” and “Taken Singly.” In the first, and
more interesting, of these groups, the poems are somewhat didactic, though
there are humorous and satiric pieces as well. Included here is “Two Tramps in
Mud Time,” which opens with the story of two itinerant lumbermen who offer to
cut the speaker’s wood for pay; the poem then develops into a sermon on the
relationship between work and play, vocation and avocation, preaching the
necessity to unite them. Of the entire volume, William Rose Benét wrote, “It is
better worth reading than nine-tenths of the books that will come your way this
year. In a time when all kinds of insanity are assailing the nations it is good
to listen to this quiet humor, even about a hen, a hornet, or Square Matthew.
... And if anybody should ask me why I still believe in my land, I have only to
put this book in his hand and answer, ‘Well-here is a man of my country.’” Most
critics acknowledge that Frost’s poetry in the 1940s and '50s grew more and
more abstract, cryptic, and even sententious, so it is generally on the basis
of his earlier work that he is judged. His politics and religious faith,
hitherto informed by skepticism and local color, became more and more the
guiding principles of his work. He had been, as Randall Jarrell points out, “a
very odd and very radical radical when young” yet became “sometimes callously
and unimaginatively conservative” in his old age. He had become a public
figure, and in the years before his death, much of his poetry was written from
this stance.
Reviewing A Witness Tree (1942) in Books,
Wilbert Snow noted a few poems “which have a right to stand with the best
things he has written”: “Come In,” “The Silken Tent,” and “Carpe Diem”
especially. Yet Snow went on: “Some of the poems here are little more than
rhymed fancies; others lack the bullet-like unity of structure to be found in
North of Boston.” On the other hand, Stephen Vincent Benet felt that Frost had
“never written any better poems than some of those in this book.” Similarly,
critics were let down by In the Clearing (1962). One wrote, “Although this
reviewer considers Robert Frost to be the foremost contemporary U.S. poet, he
regretfully must state that most of the poems in this new volume are
disappointing. ... [They] often are closer to jingles than to the memorable
poetry we associate with his name.” Another maintained that “the bulk of the
book consists of poems of ‘philosophic talk.’ Whether you like them or not
depends mostly on whether you share the ‘philosophy.’”
Indeed,
many readers do share Frost’s philosophy, and still others who do not
nevertheless continue to find delight and significance in his large body of
poetry. In October, 1963, President John F. Kennedy delivered a speech at the
dedication of the Robert Frost Library in Amherst, Massachusetts. “In honoring
Robert Frost,” the President said, “we therefore can pay honor to the deepest
source of our national strength. That strength takes many forms and the most
obvious forms are not always the most significant. ... Our national strength
matters; but the spirit which informs and controls our strength matters just as
much. This was the special significance of Robert Frost.” The poet would
probably have been pleased by such recognition, for he had said once, in an
interview with Harvey Breit: “One thing I care about, and wish young people
could care about, is taking poetry as the first form of understanding. If
poetry isn’t understanding all, the whole world, then it isn’t worth anything.”
Frost’s poetry is revered to this day. When a
previously unknown poem by Frost titled “War Thoughts at Home,” was discovered
and dated to 1918, it was subsequently published in the Fall 2006 issue of the
Virginia Quarterly Review. The first edition Frost’s Notebooks were published
in 2009, and thousands of errors were corrected in the paperback edition years
later. A critical edition of his Collected Prose was published in 2010 to broad
critical acclaim. A multi-volume series of his Collected Letters is now in
production, with the first volume appearing in 2014 and the second in 2016.
Robert
Frost continues to hold a unique and almost isolated position in American
letters. “Though his career fully spans the modern period and though it is
impossible to speak of him as anything other than a modern poet,” writes James
M. Cox, “it is difficult to place him in the main tradition of modern poetry.”
In a sense, Frost stands at the crossroads of 19th-century American poetry and
modernism, for in his verse may be found the culmination of many 19th-century
tendencies and traditions as well as parallels to the works of his 20th-century
contemporaries. Taking his symbols from the public domain, Frost developed, as
many critics note, an original, modern idiom and a sense of directness and
economy that reflect the imagism of Ezra Pound and Amy Lowell. On the other
hand, as Leonard Unger and William Van O’Connor point out in Poems for Study,
“Frost’s poetry, unlike that of such contemporaries as Eliot, Stevens, and the
later Yeats, shows no marked departure from the poetic practices of the
nineteenth century.” Although he avoids traditional verse forms and only uses
rhyme erratically, Frost is not an innovator and his technique is never
experimental.
Frost’s theory of poetic composition ties him
to both centuries. Like the 19th-century Romantic poets, he maintained that a
poem is “never a put-up job. ... It begins as a lump in the throat, a sense of
wrong, a homesickness, a loneliness. It is never a thought to begin with. It is
at its best when it is a tantalizing vagueness.” Yet, “working out his own
version of the ‘impersonal’ view of art,” as Hyatt H. Waggoner observed, Frost
also upheld T.S. Eliot’s idea that the man who suffers and the artist who
creates are totally separate. In a 1932 letter to Sydney Cox, Frost explained
his conception of poetry: “The objective idea is all I ever cared about. Most
of my ideas occur in verse. ... To be too subjective with what an artist has
managed to make objective is to come on him presumptuously and render
ungraceful what he in pain of his life had faith he had made graceful.”
To
accomplish such objectivity and grace, Frost took up 19th-century tools and
made them new. Lawrance Thompson has explained that, according to Frost, “the
self-imposed restrictions of meter in form and of coherence in content” work to
a poet’s advantage; they liberate him from the experimentalist’s burden—the perpetual
search for new forms and alternative structures. Thus Frost, as he himself put
it in “The Constant Symbol,” wrote his verse regular; he never completely
abandoned conventional metrical forms for free verse, as so many of his
contemporaries were doing. At the same time, his adherence to meter, line
length, and rhyme scheme was not an arbitrary choice. He maintained that “the
freshness of a poem belongs absolutely to its not having been thought out and
then set to verse as the verse in turn might be set to music.” He believed,
rather, that the poem’s particular mood dictated or determined the poet’s
“first commitment to metre and length of line.”
Critics frequently point out that Frost
complicated his problem and enriched his style by setting traditional meters
against the natural rhythms of speech. Drawing his language primarily from the
vernacular, he avoided artificial poetic diction by employing the accent of a
soft-spoken New Englander. In The Function of Criticism, Yvor Winters faulted
Frost for his “endeavor to make his style approximate as closely as possible
the style of conversation.” But what Frost achieved in his poetry was much more
complex than a mere imitation of the New England farmer idiom. He wanted to
restore to literature the “sentence sounds that underlie the words,” the “vocal
gesture” that enhances meaning. That is, he felt the poet’s ear must be
sensitive to the voice in order to capture with the written word the
significance of sound in the spoken word. “The Death of the Hired Man,” for
instance, consists almost entirely of dialogue between Mary and Warren, her
farmer-husband, but critics have observed that in this poem Frost takes the
prosaic patterns of their speech and makes them lyrical. To Ezra Pound “The
Death of the Hired Man” represented Frost at his best—when he “dared to write
... in the natural speech of New England; in natural spoken speech, which is
very different from the ‘natural’ speech of the newspapers, and of many
professors.”
Frost’s use of New England dialect is only one
aspect of his often discussed regionalism. Within New England, his particular
focus was on New Hampshire, which he called “one of the two best states in the
Union,” the other being Vermont. In an essay entitled “Robert Frost and New
England: A Revaluation,” W.G. O’Donnell noted how from the start, in A Boy’s
Will, “Frost had already decided to give his writing a local habitation and a
New England name, to root his art in the soil that he had worked with his own
hands.” Reviewing North of Boston in the New Republic, Amy Lowell wrote, “Not
only is his work New England in subject, it is so in technique. ... Mr. Frost
has reproduced both people and scenery with a vividness which is
extraordinary.” Many other critics have lauded Frost’s ability to realistically
evoke the New England landscape; they point out that one can visualize an
orchard in “After Apple-Picking” or imagine spring in a farmyard in “Two Tramps
in Mud Time.” In this “ability to portray the local truth in nature,” O’Donnell
claims, Frost has no peer. The same ability prompted Pound to declare, “I know
more of farm life than I did before I had read his poems. That means I know
more of ‘Life.’”
Frost’s regionalism, critics remark, is in his
realism, not in politics; he creates no picture of regional unity or sense of
community. In The Continuity of American Poetry, Roy Harvey Pearce describes
Frost’s protagonists as individuals who are constantly forced to confront their
individualism as such and to reject the modern world in order to retain their
identity. Frost’s use of nature is not only similar but closely tied to this
regionalism. He stays as clear of religion and mysticism as he does of
politics. What he finds in nature is sensuous pleasure; he is also sensitive to
the earth’s fertility and to man’s relationship to the soil. To critic M.L.
Rosenthal, Frost’s pastoral quality, his “lyrical and realistic repossession of
the rural and ‘natural,’” is the staple of his reputation.
Yet,
just as Frost is aware of the distances between one man and another, so he is
also always aware of the distinction, the ultimate separateness, of nature and
man. Marion Montgomery has explained, “His attitude toward nature is one of
armed and amicable truce and mutual respect interspersed with crossings of the
boundaries” between individual man and natural forces. Below the surface of
Frost’s poems are dreadful implications, what Rosenthal calls his “shocked
sense of the helpless cruelty of things.” This natural cruelty is at work in
“Design” and in “Once by the Pacific.” The ominous tone of these two poems
prompted Rosenthal’s further comment: “At his most powerful Frost is as
staggered by ‘the horror’ as Eliot and approaches the hysterical edge of
sensibility in a comparable way. ... His is still the modern mind in search of
its own meaning.”
The austere and tragic view of life that
emerges in so many of Frost’s poems is modulated by his metaphysical use of
detail. As Frost portrays him, man might be alone in an ultimately indifferent
universe, but he may nevertheless look to the natural world for metaphors of
his own condition. Thus, in his search for meaning in the modern world, Frost
focuses on those moments when the seen and the unseen, the tangible and the
spiritual intersect. John T. Napier calls this Frost’s ability “to find the
ordinary a matrix for the extraordinary.” In this respect, he is often compared
with Emily Dickinson and Ralph Waldo Emerson, in whose poetry, too, a simple
fact, object, person, or event will be transfigured and take on greater mystery
or significance. The poem “Birches” is an example: it contains the image of
slender trees bent to the ground temporarily by a boy’s swinging on them or
permanently by an ice-storm. But as the poem unfolds, it becomes clear that the
speaker is concerned not only with child’s play and natural phenomena, but also
with the point at which physical and spiritual reality merge.
Such symbolic import of mundane facts informs
many of Frost’s poems, and in “Education by Poetry” he explained: “Poetry
begins in trivial metaphors, pretty metaphors, ‘grace’ metaphors, and goes on
to the profoundest thinking that we have. Poetry provides the one permissible
way of saying one thing and meaning another. ... Unless you are at home in the
metaphor, unless you have had your proper poetical education in the metaphor,
you are not safe anywhere.”
Works
of Robert Frost
The
poems in Frost’s early books, especially North of Boston, differ radically from
late 19th-century Romantic verse with its ever-benign view of nature, its
didactic emphasis, and its slavish conformity to established verse forms and
themes. Lowell called North of Boston a “sad” book, referring to its portraits
of inbred, isolated, and psychologically troubled rural New Englanders. These
off-mainstream portraits signaled Frost’s departure from the old tradition and
his own fresh interest in delineating New England characters and their
formative background. Among these psychological investigations are the
alienated life of Silas in “The Death of the Hired Man,” the inability of Amy
in “Home Burial” to walk the difficult path from grief back to normality, the
rigid mindset of the neighbour in “Mending Wall,” and the paralyzing fear that
twists the personality of Doctor Magoon in “A Hundred Collars.”
The
natural world, for Frost, wore two faces. Early on he overturned the Emersonian
concept of nature as healer and mentor in a poem in A Boy’s Will entitled
“Storm Fear,” a grim picture of a blizzard as a raging beast that dares the
inhabitants of an isolated house to come outside and be killed. Later, in such
poems as “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening” and “The Hill Wife,” the benign
surface of nature cloaks potential dangers, and death itself lurks behind dark,
mysterious trees. Nature’s frolicsome aspect predominates in other poems such
as “Birches,” where a destructive ice storm is recalled as a thing of memorable
beauty. Although Frost is known to many as essentially a “happy” poet, the
tragic elements in life continued to mark his poems, from “‘Out, Out—’” (1916),
in which a lad’s hand is severed and life ended, to a fine verse entitled “The
Fear of Man” from Steeple Bush, in which human release from pervading fear is
contained in the image of a breathless dash through the nighttime city from the
security of one faint street lamp to another just as faint. Even in his final
volume, In the Clearing, so filled with the stubborn courage of old age, Frost
portrays human security as a rather tiny and quite vulnerable opening in a
thickly grown forest, a pinpoint of light against which the encroaching trees
cast their very real threat of darkness.
Frost
demonstrated an enviable versatility of theme, but he most commonly
investigated human contacts with the natural world in small encounters that
serve as metaphors for larger aspects of the human condition. He often
portrayed the human ability to turn even the slightest incident or natural
detail to emotional profit, seen at its most economical form in “Dust of Snow”:
The
way a crow
Shook
down on me
The
dust of snow
From
a hemlock tree
Has
given my heart
A
change of mood
And
saved some part
Of
a day I had rued.
Other
poems are portraits of the introspective mind possessed by its own private
demons, as in “Desert Places,” which could serve to illustrate Frost’s celebrated
definition of poetry as a “momentary stay against confusion”:
They
cannot scare me with their empty spaces
Between
stars—on stars where no human race is.
I
have it in me so much nearer home
To
scare myself with my own desert places.
Frost
was widely admired for his mastery of metrical form, which he often set against
the natural rhythms of everyday, unadorned speech. In this way the traditional
stanza and metrical line achieved new vigour in his hands. Frost’s command of
traditional metrics is evident in the tight, older, prescribed patterns of such
sonnets as “Design” and “The Silken Tent.” His strongest allegiance probably
was to the quatrain with simple rhymes such as abab and abcb, and within its
restrictions he was able to achieve an infinite variety, as in the
aforementioned “Dust of Snow” and “Desert Places.” Frost was never an
enthusiast of free verse and regarded its looseness as something less than
ideal, similar to playing tennis without a net. His determination to be “new”
but to employ “old ways to be new” set him aside from the radical
experimentalism of the advocates of vers libre in the early 20th century. On
occasion Frost did employ free verse to advantage, one outstanding example
being “After Apple-Picking,” with its random pattern of long and short lines
and its nontraditional use of rhyme. Here he shows his power to stand as a
transitional figure between the old and the new in poetry. Frost mastered blank
verse (i.e., unrhymed verse in iambic pentameter) for use in such dramatic narratives
as “Mending Wall” and “Home Burial,” becoming one of the few modern poets to
use it both appropriately and well. His chief technical innovation in these
dramatic-dialogue poems was to unify the regular pentameter line with the
irregular rhythms of conversational speech. Frost’s blank verse has the same
terseness and concision that mark his poetry in general.
Legacy
Frost
was the most widely admired and highly honoured American poet of the 20th
century. Amy Lowell thought he had overstressed the dark aspects of New England
life, but Frost’s later flood of more uniformly optimistic verses made that
view seem antiquated. Louis Untermeyer’s judgment that the dramatic poems in
North of Boston were the most authentic and powerful of their kind ever produced
by an American has only been confirmed by later opinions. Gradually, Frost’s
name ceased to be linked solely with New England, and he gained broad
acceptance as a national poet.
It
is true that certain criticisms of Frost have never been wholly refuted, one
being that he was overly interested in the past, another that he was too little
concerned with the present and future of American society. Those who criticize
Frost’s detachment from the “modern” emphasize the undeniable absence in his
poems of meaningful references to the modern realities of industrialization,
urbanization, and the concentration of wealth, or to such familiar items as
radios, motion pictures, automobiles, factories, or skyscrapers. The poet has
been viewed as a singer of sweet nostalgia and a social and political
conservative who was content to sigh for the good things of the past.
Such
views have failed to gain general acceptance, however, in the face of the
universality of Frost’s themes, the emotional authenticity of his voice, and
the austere technical brilliance of his verse. Frost was often able to endow
his rural imagery with a larger symbolic or metaphysical significance, and his
best poems transcend the immediate realities of their subject matter to
illuminate the unique blend of tragic endurance, stoicism, and tenacious
affirmation that marked his outlook on life. Over his long career, Frost
succeeded in lodging more than a few poems where, as he put it, they would be
“hard to get rid of,” among them “The Road Not Taken” (published in 1915, with
its meaning disputed ever since). He can be said to have lodged himself just as
solidly in the affections of his fellow Americans. For thousands he remains the
only recent poet worth reading and the only one who matters.
Style
and critical reception
Critic
Harold Bloom argued that Frost was one of "the major American poets".
The
poet and critic Randall Jarrell often praised Frost's poetry and wrote
"Robert Frost, along with Stevens and Eliot, seems to me the greatest of
the American poets of this century. Frost's virtues are extraordinary. No other
living poet has written so well about the actions of ordinary men; his
wonderful dramatic monologues or dramatic scenes come out of a knowledge of
people that few poets have had, and they are written in a verse that uses,
sometimes with absolute mastery, the rhythms of actual speech". He also
praised "Frost's seriousness and honesty", stating that Frost was
particularly skilled at representing a wide range of human experience in his
poems.
Jarrell's
notable and influential essays on Frost include the essays "Robert Frost's
'Home Burial'" (1962), which consisted of an extended close reading of
that particular poem, and "To The Laodiceans" (1952) in which Jarrell
defended Frost against critics who had accused Frost of being too
"traditional" and out of touch with Modern or Modernist poetry.
In
Frost's defense, Jarrell wrote "the regular ways of looking at Frost's
poetry are grotesque simplifications, distortions, falsifications—coming to
know his poetry well ought to be enough, in itself, to dispel any of them, and
to make plain the necessity of finding some other way of talking about his
work." And Jarrell's close readings of poems like "Neither Out Too
Far Nor In Too Deep" led readers and critics to perceive more of the
complexities in Frost's poetry.
In
an introduction to Jarrell's book of essays, Brad Leithauser notes that
"the 'other' Frost that Jarrell discerned behind the genial, homespun New
England rustic—the 'dark' Frost who was desperate, frightened, and brave—has
become the Frost we've all learned to recognize, and the little-known poems
Jarrell singled out as central to the Frost canon are now to be found in most
anthologies". Jarrell lists a selection of the Frost poems he considers
the most masterful, including "The Witch of Coös", "Home
Burial", "A Servant to Servants", "Directive",
"Neither Out Too Far Nor In Too Deep", "Provide, Provide",
"Acquainted with the Night", "After Apple Picking",
"Mending Wall", "The Most of It", "An Old Man's Winter
Night", "To Earthward", "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy
Evening", "Spring Pools", "The Lovely Shall Be
Choosers", "Design", and "Desert Places".
In
2003, the critic Charles McGrath noted that critical views on Frost's poetry
have changed over the years (as has his public image). In an article called
"The Vicissitudes of Literary Reputation," McGrath wrote,
"Robert Frost ... at the time of his death in 1963 was generally
considered to be a New England folkie ... In 1977, the third volume of Lawrance
Thompson's biography suggested that Frost was a much nastier piece of work than
anyone had imagined; a few years later, thanks to the reappraisal of critics
like William H. Pritchard and Harold Bloom and of younger poets like Joseph
Brodsky, he bounced back again, this time as a bleak and unforgiving
modernist."
In
The Norton Anthology of Modern Poetry, editors Richard Ellmann and Robert
O'Clair compared and contrasted Frost's unique style to the work of the poet
Edwin Arlington Robinson since they both frequently used New England settings
for their poems. However, they state that Frost's poetry was "less
[consciously] literary" and that this was possibly due to the influence of
English and Irish writers like Thomas Hardy and W.B. Yeats. They note that
Frost's poems "show a successful striving for utter colloquialism"
and always try to remain down to earth, while at the same time using
traditional forms despite the trend of American poetry towards free verse which
Frost famously said was "'like playing tennis without a net.'"
In
providing an overview of Frost's style, the Poetry Foundation makes the same
point, placing Frost's work "at the crossroads of nineteenth-century
American poetry [with regard to his use of traditional forms] and modernism
[with his use of idiomatic language and ordinary, everyday subject
matter]." They also note that Frost believed that "the self-imposed
restrictions of meter in form" was more helpful than harmful because he
could focus on the content of his poems instead of concerning himself with
creating "innovative" new verse forms.
An
earlier 1963 study by the poet James Radcliffe Squires spoke to the distinction
of Frost as a poet whose verse soars more for the difficulty and skill by which
he attains his final visions, than for the philosophical purity of the visions
themselves. "He has written at a time when the choice for the poet seemed
to lie among the forms of despair: Science, solipsism, or the religion of the
past century ... Frost has refused all of these and in the refusal has long
seemed less dramatically committed than others ... But no, he must be seen as
dramatically uncommitted to the single solution ... Insofar as Frost allows to
both fact and intuition a bright kingdom, he speaks for many of us. Insofar as
he speaks through an amalgam of senses and sure experience so that his poetry
seems a nostalgic memory with overtones touching some conceivable future, he
speaks better than most of us. That is to say, as a poet must."
The
classicist Helen H. Bacon has proposed that Frost's deep knowledge of Greek and
Roman classics influenced much of his work. Frost's education at Lawrence High
School, Dartmouth, and Harvard "was based mainly on the classics". As
examples, she links imagery and action in Frost's early poems "Birches"
(1915) and "Wild Grapes" (1920) with Euripides' Bacchae. She cites
certain motifs, including that of the tree bent down to earth, as evidence of
his "very attentive reading of Bacchae, almost certainly in Greek".
In a later poem, "One More Brevity" (1953), Bacon compares the poetic
techniques used by Frost to those of Virgil in the Aeneid. She notes that
"this sampling of the ways Frost drew on the literature and concepts of
the Greek and Roman world at every stage of his life indicates how imbued with
it he was".
Themes
In
Contemporary Literary Criticism, the editors state that "Frost's best work
explores fundamental questions of existence, depicting with chilling starkness
the loneliness of the individual in an indifferent universe."[46] The
critic T. K. Whipple focused on this bleakness in Frost's work, stating that
"in much of his work, particularly in North of Boston, his harshest book,
he emphasizes the dark background of life in rural New England, with its
degeneration often sinking into total madness."
In
sharp contrast, the founding publisher and editor of Poetry, Harriet Monroe,
emphasized the folksy New England persona and characters in Frost's work,
writing that "perhaps no other poet in our history has put the best of the
Yankee spirit into a book so completely." She notes his frequent use of
rural settings and farm life, and she likes that in these poems, Frost is most
interested in "showing the human reaction to nature's processes." She
also notes that while Frost's narrative, character-based poems are often
satirical, Frost always has a "sympathetic humor" towards his
subjects.
Influenced
by
Robert
Graves , Rupert Brooke , Thomas Hardy , William Butler Yeats , John Keats , Ralph
Waldo Emerson ,
Influenced
Robert
Francis , Seamus Heaney , Richard Wilbur , Edward Thomas , James Wright
Selected
works
Poetry
collections
1913.
A Boy's Will. London: David Nutt (New York: Holt, 1915) , 1914. North of
Boston. London: David Nutt (New York: Holt, 1914) , "After Apple-Picking"
, "The Death of the Hired Man" , "Mending Wall" , 1916.
Mountain Interval. New York: Holt , "Birches" , "Out, Out"
, "The Oven Bird" , "The Road Not Taken" , 1923. Selected
Poems. New York: Holt."The Runaway"
Also
includes poems from first three volumes , 1923. New Hampshire. New York: Holt
(London: Grant Richards, 1924) , "Fire and Ice" , "Nothing Gold
Can Stay" , "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening" 1924. Several
Short Poems. New York: Holt , 1928. Selected Poems. New York: Holt. 1928.
West-Running Brook. New York: Holt , "Acquainted with the Night"1929.
The Lovely Shall Be Choosers, The Poetry Quartos, printed and illustrated by
Paul Johnston. Random House. 1930. Collected Poems of Robert Frost. New York:
Holt (UK: Longmans Green, 1930)1933. The Lone Striker. US: Knopf
1934.
Selected Poems: Third Edition. New York: Holt 1935. Three Poems. Hanover, NH:
Baker Library, Dartmouth College.1935. The Gold Hesperidee. Bibliophile Press.1936.
From Snow to Snow. New York: Holt.1936. A Further Range. New York: Holt (Cape,
1937) 1939. Collected Poems of Robert Frost. New York: Holt (UK: Longmans,
Green, 1939) 1942. A Witness Tree. New York: Holt (Cape, 1943) "The Gift
Outright" "A Question" "The Silken Tent" 1943. Come
In, and Other Poems. New York: Holt. 1947. Steeple Bush. New York: Holt , 1949.
Complete Poems of Robert Frost. New York: Holt (Cape, 1951) , 1951. Hard Not To
Be King. House of Books., 1954. Aforesaid. New York: Holt. , 1959. A
Remembrance Collection of New Poems. New York: Holt. , 1959. You Come Too. New
York: Holt (UK: Bodley Head, 1964)
1962.
In the Clearing. New York: Holt Rinehart & Winston 1969. The Poetry of
Robert Frost. New York: Holt Rinehart & Winston.
Plays
1929.
A Way Out: A One Act Play (Harbor Press). , 1929. The Cow's in the Corn: A One
Act Irish Play in Rhyme (Slide Mountain Press). , 1945. A Masque of Reason
(Holt). 1947. A Masque of Mercy (Holt).
Letters
1963.
The Letters of Robert Frost to Louis Untermeyer (Holt, Rinehart & Winston;
Cape, 1964).
1963.
Robert Frost and John Bartlett: The Record of a Friendship, by Margaret
Bartlett Anderson (Holt, Rinehart & Winston).
1964.
Selected Letters of Robert Frost (Holt, Rinehart & Winston).
1972.
Family Letters of Robert and Elinor Frost (State University of New York Press).
1981.
Robert Frost and Sidney Cox: Forty Years of Friendship (University Press of New
England).
2014.
The Letters of Robert Frost, Volume 1, 1886–1920, edited by Donald Sheehy, Mark
Richardson, and Robert Faggen. Belknap Press. ISBN 978-0674057609. (811 pages;
first volume, of five, of the scholarly edition of the poet's correspondence,
including many previously unpublished letters.)
2016.
The Letters of Robert Frost, Volume 2, 1920–1928, edited by Donald Sheehy, Mark
Richardson, Robert Bernard Hass, and Henry Atmore. Belknap Press. ISBN
978-0674726642. (848 pages; second volume of the series.)
Other
1957.
Robert Frost Reads His Poetry. Caedmon Records, TC1060. (spoken word)
1966.
Interviews with Robert Frost (Holt, Rinehart & Winston; Cape, 1967).
1995.
Collected Poems, Prose and Plays, edited by Richard Poirier. Library of
America. ISBN 978-1-883011-06-2. (omnibus volume.)
2007.
The Notebooks of Robert Frost, edited by Robert Faggen. Harvard University
Press.